Best Guess · Puzzle #42 · Tuesday, November 10
Best Guess: the answers
Four questions, each with one true number. Here they are with their answers, how to reason each one out, and where the number comes from. Play today's Best Guess.
1. On an average day in December 2025, how many trips did New York City's yellow taxis and app rides (Uber and Lyft) make, combined?
The answer: about 848,000. Uber and Lyft made more than five times as many trips a day as yellow cabs.
Napkin math - 8.5Mpeople in New York City
- ×1ride each a week
- ÷7days a week
≈1.21Mtrips
The true figure is about 848,000 trips (NYC Taxi & Limousine Commission). Without looking anything up, take 8.5 million people in New York City, times 1 ride each a week, divided by 7 days a week, and you get about 1.2 million trips. It's 1.4 times too high, which as a guess would still have scored 8.4 out of 10. Because only the ratio counts, anything between 420,000 trips and 1.7 million trips was worth 7.0 or more.
Source: NYC Taxi & Limousine Commission, Data Reports Monthly (Trips Per Day by license class)
2. How many pounds of pasta does the average American eat in a year?
The answer: about 20 pounds. In a National Pasta Association survey, 73% of people said they eat pasta at least once a week.
Napkin math - 52weeks a year
- ÷2weeks per 1-pound box
≈26pounds
The true figure is about 20 pounds (National Pasta Association, as of 2021). Without looking anything up, take 52 weeks a year, divided by 2 weeks per 1-pound box, and you get about 26 pounds. That comes out 1.3 times too high, and a guess that far off still scores 8.9 out of 10. The target is wider than it looks: every guess between 10 pounds and 40 pounds scores at least 7.0.
Source: National Pasta Association, Did You Know... Americans love pasta! (key message points)
3. How many pet cats live in the US?
The answer: about 73.8 million. The AVMA says the number of pet cats has stayed fairly stable since 1996, while dogs have pulled ahead.
Napkin math - 130Mhouseholds in the US
- ×0.3of them with a cat
- ×2cats in each
≈78Mcats
The answer comes to about 73.8 million cats (American Veterinary Medical Association, as of 2024). Without looking anything up, take 130 million households in the US, times 0.3 of them with a cat, times 2 cats in each, and you get about 78 million cats. That comes out 1.1 times too high, and a guess that far off still scores 9.8 out of 10. Any guess from 37 million cats to 150 million cats scores 7.0 or better, because the game only counts how many times off you are.
Source: American Veterinary Medical Association, Chart of the month: Long-term trends in pet populations
4. How many visits to doctors' offices do Americans make in a year?
The answer: about 1 billion. About half of those visits were to primary care physicians.
Napkin math - 330Mpeople in the US
- ×3visits each a year
≈990Mvisits
The true figure is about 1 billion visits (CDC National Center for Health Statistics, as of 2019). Without looking anything up, take 330 million people in the US, times 3 visits each a year, and you get about 990 million visits. That lands all but on the answer, worth 10.0 out of 10 as a guess. The target is wider than it looks: every guess between 500 million visits and 2 billion visits scores at least 7.0.