Price tags · Puzzle #44 · Thursday, November 12
Price tags: the answers
Four questions, each with one true number. Here they are with their answers, how to reason each one out, and where the number comes from. Play today's Price tags.
1. A year with a Lab: What does ASPCA Pet Health Insurance estimate a medium-size dog, like a Labrador, costs a year in food, care and supplies?

Photo: Skansken, CC BY 3.0 - Not counted
- One-time costs like a crate and spaying
The answer: about $669. Small dogs came in around $512 a year and large dogs around $1,040.
Napkin math - 12months a year
- ×$50a month on food, treats and checkups
≈$600
The true figure is about $669 (ASPCA Pet Health Insurance). To reason it out, take 12 months a year, times $50 a month on food, treats and checkups, and you get about $600. That comes out 1.1 times too low, and a guess that far off still scores 9.5 out of 10. Because only the ratio counts, anything between $330 and $1,300 was worth 7.0 or more.
Source: ASPCA Pet Health Insurance, How Much Does It Cost to Have a Dog?
2. Duolingo: How much did Duolingo learners spend on the app (total bookings) in 2025?
- Paid subscribers
- 12.2 million at the end of 2025
The answer: about $1.16 billion. Duolingo's bookings grew 33% in 2025, from $870.6 million the year before.
Napkin math - 10Msubscribers paying
- ×$8each a month
- ×12months a year
≈$960M
The true figure is about $1.16 billion (Duolingo, Inc.). On a napkin, take 10 million subscribers paying, times $8 each a month, times 12 months a year, and you get about $960 million. The estimate is 1.2 times too low, close enough to score 9.2 out of 10. Because only the ratio counts, anything between $580 million and $2.3 billion was worth 7.0 or more.
Source: Duolingo, Inc. (SEC Form 8-K, Exhibit 99.1), Q4 2025 Shareholder Letter
3. T206 Honus Wagner card: What did a T206 Honus Wagner baseball card graded SGC 2 sell for in a private sale through Goldin in August 2022?

Photo: Published by the American Tobacco Company. Photograph by the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum., Public domain - What
- A 1909–1911 T206 Honus Wagner card, graded 2 out of 10
- Rarity
- Fewer than 50 authenticated copies exist
- Sold
- Private sale through Goldin, 2022
The answer: $7.25 million. It beat the previous record, set by a better-graded SGC 3 copy the year before.
Napkin math: It's the most famous rare card in the hobby, but this copy is in poor shape, so think high single-digit millions.
The answer comes to $7.25 million (USA Today, as of August 2022). There's no tidy chain of numbers for this one, so the skill is a sense of scale: the answer is in the millions. Any guess from $3.6 million to $15 million scores 7.0 or better, because the game only counts how many times off you are.
Source: USA Today, Holy Grail of baseball cards — a Honus Wagner T-206 — sells for record $7.25 million
4. An Olympic pool of milk: At the US average store price of whole milk in August 2026, what would it cost to fill an Olympic swimming pool with milk?

Photo: Cabrils, CC BY-SA 4.0 - Pool
- 50 by 25 meters, 2 meters deep
- Holds
- about 660,000 gallons
The answer: about $2.8 million. That's about 660,000 gallon jugs, each at the Bureau of Labor Statistics' city average price.
Napkin math - 660kgallons in the pool
- ×$4a gallon of milk
≈$2.64M
The real answer is about $2.8 million (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis (FRED), from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics). On a napkin, take 660,000 gallons in the pool, times $4 a gallon of milk, and you get about $2.6 million. It's 1.1 times too low, which as a guess would still have scored 9.8 out of 10. The target is wider than it looks: every guess between $1.4 million and $5.6 million scores at least 7.0.